Second impeachment of Donald Trump

Second impeachment of Donald Trump
Trump Second Impeachment Vote.png
The House of Representatives votes to adopt the article of impeachment (H.Res. 24)
Accused Donald Trump (President of the United States)
Proponents
Date January 13, 2021 (2021-01-13) ⁠–⁠ February 13, 2021 (2021-02-13)
(1 month)
Outcome Acquitted by the U.S. Senate
Charges
Cause
Congressional votes
Voting in the U.S. House of Representatives
Accusation Incitement of insurrection
Votes in favor 232
Votes against 197
Present 0
Not voting 4
Result Approved
Voting in the U.S. Senate
Accusation Incitement of insurrection
Votes in favor 57 "guilty"
Votes against 43 "not guilty"
Result Acquitted (67 "guilty" votes necessary for a conviction)

The second impeachment of Donald Trump, the 45th president of the United States, occurred on January 13, 2021, one week before his term expired. It was the fourth impeachment of a U.S. president, and the second for Trump after his first impeachment in December 2019.[1][2] Ten Republican representatives voted for the second impeachment, the most pro-impeachment votes ever from a president's party.[3] This was also the first presidential impeachment in which all majority caucus members voted unanimously for impeachment.

The House of Representatives of the 117th U.S. Congress adopted one article of impeachment against Trump of "incitement of insurrection", alleging that he had incited the January 6 attack of the U.S. Capitol. These events were preceded by numerous unsuccessful attempts by Trump to overturn the 2020 presidential election, as well as his pushing of voter fraud conspiracy theories on his social media channels before, during, and after the election.[4] A single article of impeachment charging Trump with "incitement of insurrection" against the U.S. government and "lawless action at the Capitol" was introduced to the House of Representatives on January 11, 2021.[5] The article was introduced with more than 200 co-sponsors.[6] The same day, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi gave Vice President Mike Pence an ultimatum to invoke Section 4 of the 25th Amendment to assume the role of acting president within 24 hours, or the House would proceed with impeachment proceedings.[7][8] Pence stated that he would not do so in a letter to Pelosi the following day, arguing that to do so would not "be in the best interest of our Nation or consistent with our Constitution".[9] Nevertheless, a House majority, including Republican Adam Kinzinger passed a resolution urging Pence to invoke the 25th Amendment.[10]

The House impeachment managers formally triggered the start of the impeachment trial on January 25 by delivering to the Senate the charge against Trump. The nine managers walked into the Senate chamber led by the lead impeachment manager, Representative Jamie Raskin, who read the article of impeachment.[11] The trial in the Senate was scheduled to start on February 9.[12] The trial was the first of its kind for a departed U.S. president, with Andrew Johnson, Bill Clinton, and Trump having each been the incumbent in prior impeachment trials; as a result, Chief Justice John Roberts chose not to preside as he had done for Trump's first impeachment trial (the president pro tempore of the Senate, Vermont senator Patrick Leahy, presided instead[11][13]), and arguments favoring the conviction of Trump cited the Senate's 1876 conviction of Ulysses S. Grant's Secretary of War William W. Belknap, who was impeached and convicted after leaving office.[14] At the trial, 57 senators voted "guilty", which was less than the two-thirds majority needed (67) to convict Trump, and 43 senators voted "not guilty", resulting in Trump being acquitted of the charges on February 13, 2021.[15]

Background

Attempts to overturn the 2020 election

For weeks prior to the impeachment, President Trump made numerous unsuccessful attempts to overturn the 2020 United States presidential election.

2021 U.S. Capitol attack

Trump called on his supporters to come to Washington D.C. on January 6, on the day that Congress was counting the electoral votes, to the "March to Save America" rally on the National Mall. At the rally, Trump as well as other speakers repeated the false claims that the election was stolen, used the word "fight",[16] made an analogy to boxing,[16] and suggested that his supporters had the power to prevent President-elect Joe Biden from taking office.[17]

When the United States Congress convened to certify the electoral votes of the presidential election, supporters of Trump crossed the Mall and stormed the United States Capitol in an attempt to prevent the tabulation of votes and protest against Biden's win. Trump supporters unlawfully entered the Capitol and gathered on both its eastern and western sides, including on the inaugural platform constructed for Biden's inauguration.[18] Five people, including a Capitol Police officer, died as a result of the riots, while several improvised explosive devices were found on and near the Capitol grounds.[19][20] Another Capitol police officer on duty during the riots died by suicide days later.[21] During the riots, Trump was "initially pleased" by the attack on the Capitol and took no action.[22][23] In a speech hours into the event, Trump told the rioters "We love you. You're very special," restated his false claims of electoral fraud, and then asked them to go home.[24] Hours later, Congress reconvened and ultimately certified the electoral votes in the early morning hours of January 7. Trump then released a statement asserting that there would be an "orderly transition" of power on Inauguration Day, even while continuing to falsely claim that the election was "stolen" from him and also stating that he would not attend Biden's inauguration.[25]

Considered scenarios

Four scenarios for the removal of Trump from office had been posited by members of Congress, members of Trump's cabinet, political commentators, or legal scholars: resignation, the invocation of the 14th Amendment, invocation of the 25th Amendment, or impeachment and conviction.

Resignation

The President of the United States can resign from office, in which case the Vice President will automatically become president, instead of merely assuming the powers and duties of the presidency as acting president. While Article II of the Constitution states that the "Powers and Duties" of the president devolve to the vice president in the event of the president's death, resignation, incapacity, or removal, John Tyler interpreted that provision as allowing the Vice President to ascend to the presidency in such cases, without any qualifications. This practice was codified in 1967, with the passage of the 25th Amendment.

If Trump had resigned, Vice President Mike Pence would have become the 46th president of the United States; Pence would have been the shortest-serving president ever, being in office for a matter of days before handing power to Joe Biden as the 47th president on January 20. This would have surpassed the record of William Henry Harrison, who died 31 days into his term. It would have been the second time in history that a president would be forced to resign; the first was the 1974 resignation of Richard Nixon when it appeared inevitable that he would be impeached and removed from office for his role in the Watergate scandal.

Due to intense pressure on his administration, the threat of removal, and numerous resignations, Trump committed to an orderly transition of power in a televised speech on January 7.[26] In the White House on January 8, Trump mentioned that he was not considering resignation.[27] On January 9, The New York Times reported that Trump told White House aides that he regretted his statement committing to an orderly transition of power and that there was no chance he would resign from office.[28]

14th Amendment

The Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution is one of the Reconstruction Amendments. It addresses citizenship rights and equal protection under the law and was proposed in response to issues related to former slaves following the American Civil War. Section 3 states that a person who participated in insurrection after having taken an oath to support the Constitution is disqualified from holding future office unless permitted by Congress.

If Trump had been removed from office under Section 3 of the 14th Amendment, Pence would have become the 46th president of the United States, and he would still have been the shortest-serving president ever before handing power to Biden as the 47th president on January 20. It would also be the first time that Section 3 of the 14th Amendment was invoked since 1919 when it stopped Victor L. Berger, convicted of violating the Espionage Act for his anti-militarist views, from taking his seat in the House of Representatives.[29] It would also be the first time that it would be invoked on a sitting president and was seen as especially unlikely.[30]

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez was one of the House Democrats that supported invoking the 14th Amendment against Trump. In a letter, Pelosi thanked her colleagues for their contributions to discussions on the 14th Amendment.[31] If successful, the former President would be ineligible for appointment to any federal office without a Senate supermajority vote in favor.

25th Amendment

The Twenty-fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution deals with presidential succession and disability. Though the amendment thus far has been used in medical situations, Section 4 provides that the vice president, together with a majority of Cabinet secretaries, may declare the president unable to carry out his duties, after which the vice president immediately assumes the duties of the president.

If Section 4 of the 25th Amendment action had been carried out, it would have made Pence the acting president, assuming the "powers and duties of the office" of the president. Trump would have remained president for the rest of his term, albeit stripped of all authority. Section 4 of the 25th Amendment has not been invoked before.[32][33] The 25th Amendment, however, was initially created for the case where the President was incapacitated.

Pence, who would have been required to initiate removal, stated that he would not invoke the 25th Amendment against Trump.[34]

Impeachment and conviction

Impeachment begins in the House of Representatives, where articles of impeachment are drawn up. These articles are then voted on by House members. Each article is voted on separately and requires a simple majority to pass. Once an article has been passed in the House, the president has been impeached. The articles are then sent to the Senate for adjudication with an impeachment trial. After views have been laid out in the trial, the Senate moves to vote on conviction. Each article requires a two-thirds majority of Senators present to pass. If an article passes in the Senate, the president has been convicted and is removed from office. Once the president is convicted, a further vote may then be held which determines whether the (now-former) president is barred from holding future office; this vote passes with a simple majority in the Senate.[35][36]

Because the Senate was not scheduled to reconvene until January 19, 2021,[37] members of Congress discussed holding the trial after Trump had left office. A former president had never been tried by the Senate; however, Secretary of War William W. Belknap was impeached by the House and tried by the Senate after he had resigned.[14]

Invoking the 25th Amendment

House Resolution 21—Calling on Vice President Michael R. Pence to convene and mobilize the principal officers of the executive departments of the Cabinet to activate section 4 of the 25th Amendment to declare President Donald J. Trump incapable of executing the duties of his office and to immediately exercise powers as acting president.
Pence's letter to Pelosi rejecting to invoke the 25th Amendment to strip Trump of his powers

On the evening of January 6, CBS News reported that Cabinet members were discussing invoking the 25th Amendment.[38] The ten Democrats on the House Judiciary Committee, led by U.S. Representative David Cicilline, sent a letter to Pence to "emphatically urge" him to invoke the 25th Amendment and declare Trump "unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office", claiming that he incited and condoned the riots.[39][40] For invocation, Pence and at least eight Cabinet members, forming a simple majority, would have to consent. Additionally, if challenged by Trump, the second invocation would maintain Pence as acting president, subject to a vote of approval in both houses of Congress, with a two-thirds supermajority necessary in each chamber to sustain. However, Congress would not have needed to act before January 20 for Pence to remain acting president until Biden was inaugurated, per the timeline described in Section 4.

Senator Elizabeth Warren (DMA) accused Education Secretary Betsy DeVos in a tweet of quitting rather than supporting efforts to invoke the 25th Amendment to remove Trump.[41] A Trump administration official disputed Warren's claim.[41] House majority whip Jim Clyburn on Friday accused DeVos and Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao of "running away from their responsibility" by resigning from President Trump's Cabinet before invoking the 25th Amendment to remove him from office.[42] Multiple news agencies reported that DeVos was in discussions to invoke the 25th Amendment prior to her resignation.[41] By late January 9, it was reported that Pence had not ruled out invoking the 25th Amendment and was actively considering it.[43][needs update]

The House Rules Committee met on January 12, 2021, to vote on a non-binding resolution calling on Pence to invoke the 25th Amendment.[6] Pence later reiterated his position of not invoking the 25th Amendment, according to a letter sent to Pelosi late on January 12. In it, he stated that the 25th Amendment was intended for presidential incapacity or disability, and invoking Section 4 to punish and usurp President Trump in the middle of a presidential transition would undermine and set a terrible precedent for the stability of the executive branch and the United States federal government.[44]

On the same day, the House of Representatives voted to call for Pence to invoke the 25th Amendment. The resolution passed with 223 in favor, 205 against, and 5 (all Republicans)[a] not voting; Adam Kinzinger was the only Republican to join a unified Democratic Caucus.[45]

Raskin bill

The 25th Amendment allows Congress to establish a committee to determine when a president is unfit to serve (section 4 of the Amendment provides that the "declaration that the President is unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office" is made by "the Vice President and a majority of either the principal officers of the executive departments [i.e., the Cabinet] or of such other body as Congress may by law provide").[46] However, such a committee has never been established. In May 2017, Representative Jamie Raskin (DMD-8) introduced legislation to create a standing, independent, nonpartisan body, called the Oversight Commission on Presidential Capacity, to make such a determination. The bill had 20 cosponsors.[47] Raskin had previously introduced a legislative proposal under the same title with the same purpose back in 2017.

In October 2020, Raskin and Pelosi introduced a similar bill to create a Commission on Presidential Capacity to Discharge the Powers and Duties of Office, to have 17 members – four physicians, four psychiatrists, four retired Democratic statespersons, and four retired Republican statespersons appointed by congressional leaders (the Speaker of the House, House Minority Leader, Senate Majority Leader, and Senate Minority Leader). The bill defines "retired statespersons" as former presidents, vice presidents, attorneys general, secretaries of state, defense secretaries, Treasury secretaries, and surgeons general. The committee chair would be appointed by the other members. The bill provides that no members of the commission could be a current elected official, federal employee, or active or reserve military personnel, a measure intended to avoid conflicts of interest and chain-of-command problems. A majority of the commission (nine members), plus the vice president, would need to support invoking the 25th Amendment. The bill had 38 cosponsors.[48] While the bill has received renewed interest since the Capitol incident, as with any other bill it would require passage by both houses of Congress and consideration by the president for the commission to be formed and consider invocation of Section 4.

Impeachment

Drafted articles of impeachment

Within hours of the Capitol attack, multiple members of Congress began to call for the impeachment of Donald Trump as president. Several representatives began the process of independently drafting various articles of impeachment. Of these attempts, the first to become public were those of Representative Ilhan Omar (DMN-5) who drafted and introduced articles of impeachment against Trump.[49][50][51][52]

Representative David Cicilline (DRI-1) separately drafted an article of impeachment. The text was obtained by CNN on January 8.[53] On Twitter, Cicilline acknowledged the coauthorship of Ted Lieu and Jamie Raskin,[54] and said that "more than 110" members had signed on to this article.[55] "Article I: Incitement of Insurrection" accuses Trump of having "willfully made statements that encouraged—and foreseeably resulted in—imminent lawless action at the Capitol".[56] As a result of incitement by Trump, "a mob unlawfully breached the Capitol" and "engaged in violent, deadly, destructive, and seditious acts".[57] On January 10, it was announced that the bill had gathered 210 cosponsors in the House.[58]

Article of impeachment introduced

On January 11, 2021, U.S. Representatives David Cicilline, along with Jamie Raskin and Ted Lieu, introduced an article of impeachment against Trump, charging Trump with "incitement of insurrection" in urging his supporters to march on the Capitol building. The article contended that Trump made several statements that "encouraged—and foreseeably resulted in—lawless action" that interfered with Congress' constitutional duty to certify the election. It argued that by his actions, Trump "threatened the integrity of the democratic system, interfered with the peaceful transition of power, and imperiled a coequal branch of Government," doing so in a way that rendered him "a threat to national security, democracy, and the Constitution" if he were allowed to complete his term.[6][59] By the time it was introduced, 218 of the 222 House Democrats had signed on as cosponsors, assuring its passage.[60] Trump was impeached in a vote on January 13, 2021; ten Republicans, including House Republican Conference chairwoman Liz Cheney, joined all of the Democrats in supporting the article.

On January 12, with the article's passage assured, Pelosi named Raskin, Lieu, Cicilline, Diana DeGette, Joaquin Castro, Eric Swalwell, Joe Neguse, Madeleine Dean, and Stacey Plaskett as managers to present the prosecution case in the Senate conviction trial, with Raskin as lead manager.[61] The managers were chosen for their expertise in constitutional law, civil rights, and criminal justice. Raskin is a former constitutional law professor at American University. Lieu is a former military prosecutor in the United States Air Force. Cicilline is a former public defender. Swalwell was a former prosecutor in California. DeGette is a former civil rights attorney. Castro, Neguse, Dean and Plaskett are all lawyers in private practice.[62]

The House impeachment managers formally triggered the start of the impeachment trial on January 25 by walking across the Capitol and delivered to the Senate the charge against Trump. The nine managers walked two-by-two led into the Senate chamber by the lead impeachment manager, who read the article of impeachment.[11] The trial in the Senate was scheduled for and began on February 9.[12]

House vote

Speaker Nancy Pelosi signs the article of impeachment following passage by the House.
Voting results on House Resolution 24[63]
(impeaching Donald John Trump, former President of the United States, for high crimes and misdemeanors)
Party Article I (incitement of insurrection)
Yes No Present Not voting
Democratic (222) 222
Republican (211) 197
Total (433)[b] 232 197 4
Result Adopted[c]
  Democratic aye
  Republican aye
  Republican nay
  Republican not voting
  Vacant seat
Full list of votes on House Resolution 24[63]
District Member Party Article I
Alabama 1 Jerry Carl Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Alabama 2 Barry Moore Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Alabama 3 Mike Rogers Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Alabama 4 Robert Aderholt Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Alabama 5 Mo Brooks Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Alabama 6 Gary Palmer Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Alabama 7 Terri Sewell Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Alaska at-large Don Young Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Arizona 1 Tom O'Halleran Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Arizona 2 Ann Kirkpatrick Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Arizona 3 Raúl Grijalva Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Arizona 4 Paul Gosar Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Arizona 5 Andy Biggs Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Arizona 6 David Schweikert Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Arizona 7 Ruben Gallego Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Arizona 8 Debbie Lesko Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Arizona 9 Greg Stanton Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Arkansas 1 Rick Crawford Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Arkansas 2 French Hill Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Arkansas 3 Steve Womack Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Arkansas 4 Bruce Westerman Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
California 1 Doug LaMalfa Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
California 2 Jared Huffman Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 3 John Garamendi Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 4 Tom McClintock Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
California 5 Mike Thompson Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 6 Doris Matsui Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 7 Ami Bera Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 8 Jay Obernolte Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
California 9 Jerry McNerney Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 10 Josh Harder Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 11 Mark DeSaulnier Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 12 Nancy Pelosi Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 13 Barbara Lee Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 14 Jackie Speier Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 15 Eric Swalwell Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 16 Jim Costa Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 17 Ro Khanna Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 18 Anna Eshoo Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 19 Zoe Lofgren Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 20 Jimmy Panetta Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 21 David Valadao Republican Green check.svg Yea
California 22 Devin Nunes Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
California 23 Kevin McCarthy Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
California 24 Salud Carbajal Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 25 Mike Garcia Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
California 26 Julia Brownley Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 27 Judy Chu Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 28 Adam Schiff Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 29 Tony Cárdenas Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 30 Brad Sherman Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 31 Pete Aguilar Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 32 Grace Napolitano Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 33 Ted Lieu Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 34 Jimmy Gomez Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 35 Norma Torres Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 36 Raul Ruiz Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 37 Karen Bass Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 38 Linda Sánchez Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 39 Young Kim Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
California 40 Lucille Roybal-Allard Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 41 Mark Takano Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 42 Ken Calvert Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
California 43 Maxine Waters Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 44 Nanette Barragán Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 45 Katie Porter Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 46 Lou Correa Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 47 Alan Lowenthal Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 48 Michelle Steel Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
California 49 Mike Levin Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 50 Darrell Issa Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
California 51 Juan Vargas Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 52 Scott Peters Democratic Green check.svg Yea
California 53 Sara Jacobs Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Colorado 1 Diana DeGette Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Colorado 2 Joe Neguse Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Colorado 3 Lauren Boebert Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Colorado 4 Ken Buck Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Colorado 5 Doug Lamborn Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Colorado 6 Jason Crow Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Colorado 7 Ed Perlmutter Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Connecticut 1 John B. Larson Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Connecticut 2 Joe Courtney Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Connecticut 3 Rosa DeLauro Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Connecticut 4 Jim Himes Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Connecticut 5 Jahana Hayes Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Delaware at-large Lisa Blunt Rochester Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 1 Matt Gaetz Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 2 Neal Dunn Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 3 Kat Cammack Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 4 John Rutherford Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 5 Al Lawson Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 6 Michael Waltz Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 7 Stephanie Murphy Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 8 Bill Posey Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 9 Darren Soto Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 10 Val Demings Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 11 Daniel Webster Republican NV
Florida 12 Gus Bilirakis Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 13 Charlie Crist Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 14 Kathy Castor Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 15 Scott Franklin Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 16 Vern Buchanan Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 17 Greg Steube Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 18 Brian Mast Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 19 Byron Donalds Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 20 Alcee Hastings Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 21 Lois Frankel Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 22 Ted Deutch Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 23 Debbie Wasserman Schultz Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 24 Frederica Wilson Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Florida 25 Mario Díaz-Balart Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 26 Carlos A. Giménez Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Florida 27 Maria Elvira Salazar Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Georgia 1 Buddy Carter Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Georgia 2 Sanford Bishop Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Georgia 3 Drew Ferguson Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Georgia 4 Hank Johnson Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Georgia 5 Nikema Williams Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Georgia 6 Lucy McBath Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Georgia 7 Carolyn Bourdeaux Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Georgia 8 Austin Scott Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Georgia 9 Andrew Clyde Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Georgia 10 Jody Hice Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Georgia 11 Barry Loudermilk Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Georgia 12 Rick W. Allen Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Georgia 13 David Scott Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Georgia 14 Marjorie Taylor Greene Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Hawaii 1 Ed Case Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Hawaii 2 Kai Kahele Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Idaho 1 Russ Fulcher Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Idaho 2 Mike Simpson Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Illinois 1 Bobby Rush Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 2 Robin Kelly Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 3 Marie Newman Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 4 Jesús "Chuy" García Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 5 Mike Quigley Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 6 Sean Casten Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 7 Danny K. Davis Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 8 Raja Krishnamoorthi Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 9 Jan Schakowsky Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 10 Brad Schneider Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 11 Bill Foster Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 12 Mike Bost Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Illinois 13 Rodney Davis Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Illinois 14 Lauren Underwood Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 15 Mary Miller Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Illinois 16 Adam Kinzinger Republican Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 17 Cheri Bustos Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Illinois 18 Darin LaHood Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Indiana 1 Frank J. Mrvan Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Indiana 2 Jackie Walorski Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Indiana 3 Jim Banks Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Indiana 4 Jim Baird Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Indiana 5 Victoria Spartz Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Indiana 6 Greg Pence Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Indiana 7 André Carson Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Indiana 8 Larry Bucshon Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Indiana 9 Trey Hollingsworth Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Iowa 1 Ashley Hinson Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Iowa 2 Mariannette Miller-Meeks Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Iowa 3 Cindy Axne Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Iowa 4 Randy Feenstra Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Kansas 1 Tracey Mann Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Kansas 2 Jake LaTurner Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Kansas 3 Sharice Davids Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Kansas 4 Ron Estes Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Kentucky 1 James Comer Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Kentucky 2 Brett Guthrie Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Kentucky 3 John Yarmuth Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Kentucky 4 Thomas Massie Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Kentucky 5 Hal Rogers Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Kentucky 6 Andy Barr Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Louisiana 1 Steve Scalise Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Louisiana 2 Cedric Richmond Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Louisiana 3 Clay Higgins Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Louisiana 4 Mike Johnson Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Louisiana 5 Vacant
Louisiana 6 Garret Graves Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Maine 1 Chellie Pingree Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Maine 2 Jared Golden Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Maryland 1 Andy Harris Republican NV
Maryland 2 Dutch Ruppersberger Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Maryland 3 John Sarbanes Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Maryland 4 Anthony G. Brown Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Maryland 5 Steny Hoyer Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Maryland 6 David Trone Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Maryland 7 Kweisi Mfume Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Maryland 8 Jaime Raskin Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Massachusetts 1 Richard Neal Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Massachusetts 2 Jim McGovern Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Massachusetts 3 Lori Trahan Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Massachusetts 4 Jake Auchincloss Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Massachusetts 5 Katherine Clark Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Massachusetts 6 Seth Moulton Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Massachusetts 7 Ayanna Pressley Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Massachusetts 8 Stephen F. Lynch Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Massachusetts 9 Bill Keating Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Michigan 1 Jack Bergman Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Michigan 2 Bill Huizenga Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Michigan 3 Peter Meijer Republican Green check.svg Yea
Michigan 4 John Moolenaar Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Michigan 5 Dan Kildee Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Michigan 6 Fred Upton Republican Green check.svg Yea
Michigan 7 Tim Walberg Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Michigan 8 Elissa Slotkin Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Michigan 9 Andy Levin Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Michigan 10 Lisa McClain Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Michigan 11 Haley Stevens Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Michigan 12 Debbie Dingell Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Michigan 13 Rashida Tlaib Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Michigan 14 Brenda Lawrence Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Minnesota 1 Jim Hagedorn Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Minnesota 2 Angie Craig Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Minnesota 3 Dean Phillips Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Minnesota 4 Betty McCollum Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Minnesota 5 Ilhan Omar Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Minnesota 6 Tom Emmer Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Minnesota 7 Michelle Fischbach Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Minnesota 8 Pete Stauber Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Mississippi 1 Trent Kelly Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Mississippi 2 Bennie Thompson Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Mississippi 3 Michael Guest Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Mississippi 4 Steven Palazzo Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Missouri 1 Cori Bush Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Missouri 2 Ann Wagner Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Missouri 3 Blaine Luetkemeyer Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Missouri 4 Vicky Hartzler Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Missouri 5 Emanuel Cleaver Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Missouri 6 Sam Graves Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Missouri 7 Billy Long Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Missouri 8 Jason Smith Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Montana at-large Matt Rosendale Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Nebraska 1 Jeff Fortenberry Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Nebraska 2 Don Bacon Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Nebraska 3 Adrian Smith Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Nevada 1 Dina Titus Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Nevada 2 Mark Amodei Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Nevada 3 Susie Lee Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Nevada 4 Steven Horsford Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Hampshire 1 Chris Pappas Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Hampshire 2 Ann McLane Kuster Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Jersey 1 Donald Norcross Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Jersey 2 Jeff Van Drew Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
New Jersey 3 Andy Kim Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Jersey 4 Chris Smith Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
New Jersey 5 Josh Gottheimer Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Jersey 6 Frank Pallone Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Jersey 7 Tom Malinowski Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Jersey 8 Albio Sires Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Jersey 9 Bill Pascrell Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Jersey 10 Donald Payne Jr. Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Jersey 11 Mikie Sherrill Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Jersey 12 Bonnie Watson Coleman Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Mexico 1 Deb Haaland Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New Mexico 2 Yvette Herrell Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
New Mexico 3 Teresa Leger Fernandez Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 1 Lee Zeldin Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
New York 2 Andrew Garbarino Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
New York 3 Thomas Suozzi Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 4 Kathleen Rice Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 5 Gregory Meeks Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 6 Grace Meng Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 7 Nydia Velázquez Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 8 Hakeem Jeffries Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 9 Yvette Clarke Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 10 Jerry Nadler Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 11 Nicole Malliotakis Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
New York 12 Carolyn Maloney Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 13 Adriano Espaillat Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 14 Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 15 Ritchie Torres Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 16 Jamaal Bowman Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 17 Mondaire Jones Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 18 Sean Patrick Maloney Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 19 Antonio Delgado Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 20 Paul Tonko Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 21 Elise Stefanik Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
New York 22 Vacant
New York 23 Tom Reed Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
New York 24 John Katko Republican Green check.svg Yea
New York 25 Joseph Morelle Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 26 Brian Higgins Democratic Green check.svg Yea
New York 27 Chris Jacobs Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
North Carolina 1 G. K. Butterfield Democratic Green check.svg Yea
North Carolina 2 Deborah K. Ross Democratic Green check.svg Yea
North Carolina 3 Greg Murphy Republican NV
North Carolina 4 David Price Democratic Green check.svg Yea
North Carolina 5 Virginia Foxx Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
North Carolina 6 Kathy Manning Democratic Green check.svg Yea
North Carolina 7 David Rouzer Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
North Carolina 8 Richard Hudson Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
North Carolina 9 Dan Bishop Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
North Carolina 10 Patrick McHenry Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
North Carolina 11 Madison Cawthorn Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
North Carolina 12 Alma Adams Democratic Green check.svg Yea
North Carolina 13 Ted Budd Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
North Dakota at-large Kelly Armstrong Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 1 Steve Chabot Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 2 Brad Wenstrup Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 3 Joyce Beatty Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Ohio 4 Jim Jordan Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 5 Bob Latta Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 6 Bill Johnson Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 7 Bob Gibbs Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 8 Warren Davidson Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 9 Marcy Kaptur Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Ohio 10 Mike Turner Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 11 Marcia Fudge Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Ohio 12 Troy Balderson Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 13 Tim Ryan Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Ohio 14 David Joyce Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 15 Steve Stivers Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Ohio 16 Anthony Gonzalez Republican Green check.svg Yea
Oklahoma 1 Kevin Hern Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Oklahoma 2 Markwayne Mullin Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Oklahoma 3 Frank Lucas Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Oklahoma 4 Tom Cole Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Oklahoma 5 Stephanie Bice Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Oregon 1 Suzanne Bonamici Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Oregon 2 Cliff Bentz Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Oregon 3 Earl Blumenauer Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Oregon 4 Peter DeFazio Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Oregon 5 Kurt Schrader Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Pennsylvania 1 Brian Fitzpatrick Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Pennsylvania 2 Brendan Boyle Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Pennsylvania 3 Dwight Evans Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Pennsylvania 4 Madeleine Dean Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Pennsylvania 5 Mary Gay Scanlon Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Pennsylvania 6 Chrissy Houlahan Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Pennsylvania 7 Susan Wild Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Pennsylvania 8 Matt Cartwright Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Pennsylvania 9 Dan Meuser Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Pennsylvania 10 Scott Perry Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Pennsylvania 11 Lloyd Smucker Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Pennsylvania 12 Fred Keller Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Pennsylvania 13 John Joyce Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Pennsylvania 14 Guy Reschenthaler Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Pennsylvania 15 Glenn Thomposon Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Pennsylvania 16 Mike Kelly Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Pennsylvania 17 Conor Lamb Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Pennsylvania 18 Mike Doyle Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Rhode Island 1 David Cicilline Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Rhode Island 2 James Langevin Democratic Green check.svg Yea
South Carolina 1 Nancy Mace Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
South Carolina 2 Joe Wilson Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
South Carolina 3 Jeff Duncan Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
South Carolina 4 William Timmons Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
South Carolina 5 Ralph Norman Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
South Carolina 6 Jim Clyburn Democratic Green check.svg Yea
South Carolina 7 Tom Rice Republican Green check.svg Yea
South Dakota at-large Dusty Johnson Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Tennessee 1 Diana Harshbarger Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Tennessee 2 Tim Burchett Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Tennessee 3 Chuck Fleischmann Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Tennessee 4 Scott DesJarlais Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Tennessee 5 Jim Cooper Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Tennessee 6 John Rose Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Tennessee 7 Mark E. Green Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Tennessee 8 David Kustoff Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Tennessee 9 Steve Cohen Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 1 Louie Gohmert Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 2 Dan Crenshaw Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 3 Van Taylor Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 4 Pat Fallon Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 5 Lance Gooden Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 6 Ron Wright Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 7 Lizzie Pannill Fletcher Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 8 Kevin Brady Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 9 Al Green Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 10 Michael McCaul Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 11 August Pfluger Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 12 Kay Granger Republican NV
Texas 13 Ronny Jackson Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 14 Randy Weber Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 15 Vicente Gonzalez Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 16 Veronica Escobar Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 17 Pete Sessions Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 18 Sheila Jackson Lee Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 19 Jodey Arrington Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 20 Joaquin Castro Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 21 Chip Roy Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 22 Troy Nehls Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 23 Tony Gonzales Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 24 Beth Van Duyne Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 25 Roger Williams Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 26 Michael C. Burgess Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 27 Michael Cloud Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 28 Henry Cuellar Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 29 Sylvia Garcia Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 30 Eddie Bernice Johnson Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 31 John Carter Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Texas 32 Colin Allred Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 33 Marc Veasey Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 34 Filemon Vela Jr. Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 35 Lloyd Doggett Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Texas 36 Brian Babin Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Utah 1 Blake Moore Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Utah 2 Chris Stewart Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Utah 3 John Curtis Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Utah 4 Burgess Owens Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Vermont at-large Peter Welch Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Virginia 1 Rob Wittman Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Virginia 2 Elaine Luria Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Virginia 3 Bobby Scott Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Virginia 4 Donald McEachin Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Virginia 5 Bob Good Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Virginia 6 Ben Cline Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Virginia 7 Abigail Spanberger Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Virginia 8 Don Beyer Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Virginia 9 Morgan Griffith Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Virginia 10 Jennifer Wexton Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Virginia 11 Gerry Connolly Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Washington 1 Suzan DelBene Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Washington 2 Rick Larsen Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Washington 3 Jaime Herrera Beutler Republican Green check.svg Yea
Washington 4 Dan Newhouse Republican Green check.svg Yea
Washington 5 Cathy McMorris Rodgers Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Washington 6 Derek Kilmer Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Washington 7 Pramila Jayapal Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Washington 8 Kim Schrier Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Washington 9 Adam Smith Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Washington 10 Marilyn Strickland Democratic Green check.svg Yea
West Virginia 1 David McKinley Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
West Virginia 2 Alex Mooney Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
West Virginia 3 Carol Miller Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Wisconsin 1 Bryan Steil Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Wisconsin 2 Mark Pocan Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Wisconsin 3 Ron Kind Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Wisconsin 4 Gwen Moore Democratic Green check.svg Yea
Wisconsin 5 Scott Fitzgerald Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Wisconsin 6 Glenn Grothman Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Wisconsin 7 Tom Tiffany Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Wisconsin 8 Mike Gallagher Republican Dark Red x.svg Nay
Wyoming at-large Liz Cheney Republican Green check.svg Yea

Senate trial

Verdict in Senate
Party Article I (incitement of insurrection)
Guilty Not guilty
Democratic (48) 48
Republican (50)
7
43
Independent (2)
2
Total (100) 57 43
Result Not guilty[d]

Opinions

Support

Individuals from media and political organizations have expressed support for Trump to be either impeached or removed through the methods outlined in the 25th Amendment. Any impeachment by the House of Representatives would, for removal, require a trial and conviction in the Senate, with the concurrence of two-thirds of Senators present and voting, during which time Trump would remain in office. As of January 8, the extent of support among Senators for an impeachment process is unclear, particularly given the length of time necessary to organize a trial and the short duration remaining of Trump's presidency.[74] Poll aggregate website FiveThirtyEight noted that roughly 85% of Democrats, 49% of Independents, and 16% of Republicans supported impeachment. The site also found roughly an 8% drop in Trump's approval ratings following the attack.[75][76]

At least 200[77][78] members of Congress have called for Trump to be impeached or stripped of his powers and duties under the 25th Amendment.[79] Other House members, as well as several state officials, have called for Trump's immediate removal by Congress under the 25th Amendment.[80][81][82][83] On January 6, four "senior Republican elected officials" told CNN that they believe Trump should be removed via the 25th Amendment, while two other Republican elected officials said Trump should be removed by impeachment.[83] On January 11, 24 former Republican members of Congress came out in support of impeachment.[84]

The day of the attack, many House Democrats, including Seth Moulton, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, and Katherine Clark, called for Trump's immediate impeachment and removal by Congress, or via the 25th Amendment.[80][81][79][85] Speaker of the United States House of Representatives Nancy Pelosi, a Democrat, urged the removal of Trump via the 25th Amendment, and announced she was prepared to vote on articles of impeachment if this does not happen.[86] Pelosi said Trump is "a very dangerous person who should not continue in office".[87] In vowing to impeach Trump again if his cabinet does not remove him themselves, Pelosi said Trump "incited an armed insurrection against America" and that "the gleeful desecration of the U.S. Capitol, which is the temple of our American democracy, and the violence targeting Congress are horrors that will forever stain our nation's history – instigated by the president."[8]

On January 6, Representatives Ted Lieu and Charlie Crist called on Vice President Mike Pence to remove Trump via the 25th Amendment.[82][88]

The first House Republican to call outright for Trump's removal from office was Adam Kinzinger; he tweeted in favor of the 25th Amendment the day after the riot.[89][90]

On January 8, CNN reported that two Republican members of the House, whom they did not name, said they would consider voting for impeachment. One explained: "We experienced the attack; we don't need long hearings on what happened."[91] Subsequently, Kinzinger, as well as John Katko, Liz Cheney, Jaime Herrera Beutler, Fred Upton, and Dan Newhouse[92] indicated they would vote in favor of impeachment; other House Republicans openly considering voting for impeachment included Peter Meijer (as of a January 11 statement).[93][94][95] Anthony Gonzalez posted a statement expressing support for impeachment to Twitter during the vote.[96] Ultimately, ten Republicans voted to impeach, including Katko, Kinzinger, Upton, Beutler, Newhouse, Meijer, Cheney and Gonzalez, as well as David Valadao of California and Tom Rice of South Carolina.[97] Four Republicans did not vote. Liz Cheney released a strong statement in support of the impeachment, which was also prominently quoted in the closing argument by House majority leader Steny Hoyer, stating that "the president of the United States summoned this mob, assembled the mob, and lit the flame of this attack. Everything that followed was his doing. (...) There has never been a greater betrayal by a President of the United States of his office and his oath to the Constitution."[98] Later the Wyoming GOP demanded that Cheney, the third highest ranking Republican in the House, resign her post. She refused to do so, and corrected some members of her state party who had claimed that the Capitol rioting was done by antifa and Black Lives Matter protesters.[99]

By January 7, Democrat Chuck Schumer, the Senate Minority Leader, had called for Trump's immediate removal from office,[100] as had many other Democratic members of the U.S. Senate.[who?][77]

On Monday, January 11, Senator Joe Manchin (D-WV) said that he thought the plan to vote on impeachment that week was "ill-advised" since there was no path to conviction by the Senate. He said Congress could move forward with impeachment after the inauguration of President-elect Biden.[101]

On January 8, Republican senator Ben Sasse said he was willing to consider an impeachment because Trump had violated his oath of office.[102]

As of January 9, no Republican senators were publicly calling for Trump's removal from office, according to CNN.[90] However, two Republican senators have called for his voluntary resignation. On January 8, Republican senator Lisa Murkowski of Alaska called on Trump to resign immediately, stating: "I want him out. He has caused enough damage."[103][104] Murkowski suggested that she might declare herself an Independent, as, "if the Republican Party has become nothing more than the party of Trump, I sincerely question whether this is the party for me."[105] Republican senator Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania stated on January 9 that he thinks President Trump "committed impeachable offenses" and that his Republican colleagues should be "soul searching" about their own involvement,[106] but he would not say how he plans to vote if the matter comes to a Senate trial.[107] On January 10, Toomey said that "the best way for our country" would be for Trump "to resign and go away as soon as possible".[108]

After Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell acknowledged Biden's victory on December 15, Trump did not speak to McConnell for the remaining month of his presidency.[109] McConnell reportedly believed that Trump had committed impeachable crimes; on Trump's last full day in office, McConnell said that "the mob was fed lies" and that "they were provoked by the president."[110] While McConnell was also said to believe that an impeachment proceeding would make it easier for Republicans to purge Trump's influence from the party,[111] he nevertheless told fellow senators on January 13 that he had not yet decided whether he would vote to convict Trump and that he would listen to the arguments during the trial.[112] Furthermore, McConnell was unwilling to convene the Senate early to hold the trial,[113] entailing that Trump finished his presidential term.

The following governors and lieutenant governors said that Trump should be removed from office:

About 175 career diplomats in the State Department, mostly lawyers, called on Mike Pompeo to support consultations with other cabinet officials on possibly invoking the 25th Amendment to remove the president from office. The cable stated that the president's actions undermined U.S. foreign policy and democratic institutions.[129]

Former Secretary of Homeland Security and White House Chief of Staff John F. Kelly, who left Trump's Cabinet in 2019, said that if he had still been part of the administration during the attack, he would have supported Trump's removal from office.[130]

More than 1,000 historians and constitutional scholars signed an open letter, posted online on January 11, 2021, calling for Trump to be impeached and removed from office.[131][132] Additionally, the American Constitution Society published a statement signed by over 900 law professors calling for Congress to impeach and remove Trump from office, or for Vice President Pence and the Cabinet invoke the 25th Amendment.[133]

Yoni Appelbaum (The Atlantic), David French (Time), Austin Sarat, David Frum (The Atlantic),[134] Tom Nichols (USA Today), David Landau, Rosalind Dixon, and Bret Stephens (The New York Times) called for the impeachment of Trump the second time and for him to be disqualified from public office.[135][136][137][138][139][140] Mary L. Trump, the President's niece, said she thought her uncle should be barred from ever running for office again.[141]

Several conservative commentators, including Meghan McCain, Rod Dreher, Daniel Larison (The American Conservative), John Podhoretz (Commentary), Tiana Lowe and Eddie Scarry (Washington Examiner) expressed their support for the impeachment and/or the invocation of the 25th Amendment to remove Trump from office.[142][143][144][145][146][147] Matthew Continetti, writing in the National Review, also called for Trump's removal from office.[148] Fox News analyst Juan Williams wrote in The Hill, "Arrest the rioters; impeach Trump".[149]

Progressive commentators John Nichols (The Nation) and Matt Ford (The New Republic) also called for Trump to be impeached and disqualified perpetually from public office.[150][151]

Calling the attack an "act of sedition", The Washington Post editorial board wrote that Trump's "continued tenure in office poses a grave threat to U.S. democracy" as well as to public order and national security, and called for Pence to immediately begin the 25th Amendment process to declare Trump "unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office" so that Pence could serve until Biden's inauguration on January 20.[152] In its first-ever staff editorial, The Dispatch stated that Trump "must be removed" for abusing his office, violating the public trust, and inciting "a violent attack on the Capitol and Congress".[153] The Financial Times editorial board called for Trump to be "held accountable for storming the Capitol".[154] The Wall Street Journal editorial board invited Trump to resign, calling his acts "impeachable" and stating that the President had "crossed a constitutional line that Mr. Trump hasn’t previously crossed".[155]

The Lincoln Project, a political action committee formed by anti-Trump Republicans and former Republicans, called for the House of Representatives and the Senate to "immediately impeach Donald Trump for directing and provoking this attack".[156]

The National Association of Manufacturers also requested Pence to "seriously consider" invoking the 25th Amendment.[157]

Freedom House issued a press release calling for the immediate removal of President Trump, through resignation, the 25th Amendment, or impeachment.[158]

The American Civil Liberties Union called for Trump's impeachment for the second time.[159]

March for Science circulated an online petition calling for Trump to be removed immediately via the 25th Amendment.[160]

Crowell & Moring LLP, a large Washington, D.C., law firm, circulated a letter among the nation's largest law firms calling for Trump's ouster under Section 4 of the Constitution's 25th Amendment. At least 18 other law firms, including DLA Piper, Foley Hoag, and Hanson Bridgett joined this call.[161][162]

Opposition

On January 7, Senator Steve Daines (R-MT) said "These calls for impeachment I'm hearing -- I don't think they're helpful, and I think we should allow 13 days to move forward peacefully and prepare for this transition of power that's going to happen on Jan. 20."[163]

On January 8, Senator Lindsey Graham (RSC) tweeted that impeachment "will do more harm than good".[164] In a follow-up tweet, he implied that Pelosi and Schumer wanted to impeach Trump because they were concerned about their own political survival.[165] Also, on January 11, Graham tweeted "It is past time for all of us to try to heal our country and move forward. Impeachment would be a major step backward."[166]

On January 11, three senators spoke out against impeachment. Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith (R-MS) said "Let's get through the 10 days. He will leave the office and let's get on with things."[167] Senator John Hoeven (R-ND) said "We need to work together to heal the divisions in our nation and impeachment would instead serve to further divide our country."[168] Senator Rick Scott (R-FL) said "I'm not going to do what the Democrats are doing. I think we need to lower the rhetoric. We need to get some unity going."[169]

On January 12, Senator Tim Scott (R-SC) tweeted "An impeachment vote will only lead to more hate and a deeply fractured nation. I oppose impeaching President Trump."[170]

On January 13, seven senators spoke out against impeachment. Senator Bill Hagerty (R-TN) said "At a time when the United States needs national healing and a true commitment to the rule of law, the American people should look to their legislators not to deepen partisan division, but to bring us together. There are seven days to go in the President's term, and he has fully committed to a peaceful transfer of power."[171] Senator Cynthia Lummis (R-WY) said "Moving forward with impeachment at this juncture will only further divide our already hurting nation."[172] Senator Kevin Cramer (R-ND) said: "The president's rhetoric, while reckless, while at some level could be accused of inciting anger and inciting some bad behavior, it is also clear that the exact words that he used do not rise to, in my mind anyway, a criminal level of incitement as we would have to consider, in my view, in this process even as political as it is."[173] Senator Marsha Blackburn (R-TN) said "To persist with impeachment now, with just days to go in the current administration, will further divide Americans and exacerbate tensions. Moving forward, it is my sincere hope Congress will work on a bipartisan basis to restore the confidence of the American people in our elections and affirm our shared commitment to the rule of law."[174] Senator Roger Wicker (R-MS) told the Meridian Star on Jan 13 that he opposes impeachment.[175] Senator Tom Cotton (R-AR) said: "After January 20, Congress should get on with the people’s business: improving our vaccination efforts, getting kids back to school, and getting workers back on the job."[176] Senator Tommy Tuberville (R-AL) said "We just need to go forward to help the people of this country and quit worrying about politics."[177]

On January 14, Senator Mike Rounds (R-SD) said "I think if the question is moot, I don't see a reason to convict."[178]

On January 19, three senators spoke out against impeachment. Senator John Cornyn (R-TX) said "If they proceed with the impeachment trial, I think that will further divide the country."[179] Senator John Thune (R-SD) said, "In my view, using a constitutional tool designed to remove the president from office after he has already left could further divide our country when we can least afford it."[180] Senator Roger Marshall (R-KS) said "Not only is it unconstitutional to impeach a President after he leaves office, I firmly believe an impeachment effort at this juncture will only raise already heated temperatures of the American public and further divide our country at a time when we should be focused on bringing the country together and moving forward. Whether it's getting the COVID-19 vaccine into the arms of all those who want and need it, boosting job recovery, or opening our economy back up to pre-pandemic levels, we have real work to do."[181]

On January 20, Senator John Boozman (R-AR) said "With [Trump] already being gone, impeachment would be a significant expense and waste of time."[182]

On January 21, five senators spoke out against impeachment. Senator Chuck Grassley (R-IA) said "It's one thing, according to the constitution, to impeach a president, but can you impeach a citizen? Because now it's not President Trump, it's citizen Trump."[183] Senator Josh Hawley (R-MO) said "Democrats appear intent on weaponizing every tool at their disposal — including pushing an unconstitutional impeachment process — to further divide the country. Missourians will not be canceled by these partisan attacks."[184] Senator Mike Braun (R-IN) said "I think the key point is, is it constitutional to do this when somebody is out of office — and then, is it purely retribution when you try to push it forward."[185] Senator Ron Johnson (R-WI) said "I believe an impeachment trial of a former president is unconstitutional and would set a very dangerous precedent."[186] Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) said ""It seems that Senate Democrats, the response they have to that is they want to start the new Congress the very first thing, with a vindictive and punitive impeachment trial,"[187]

On January 24, two senators spoke out against impeachment. Senator John Barrasso (R-WY) said Democrats were sending a message that "hatred and vitriol of Donald Trump are so strong" that they will hold a trial that stops Biden's policy priorities from moving.[188] Senator Marco Rubio (R-FL) said "The first chance I get to vote to end this trial, I will do it, because I think it's really bad for America."[189]

On January 25, three senators spoke out against impeachment. Senator Joni Ernst (R-IA) said "My concern right now is that the president is no longer in office. Congress would be opening itself to a dangerous standard of using impeachment as a tool for political revenge against a private citizen, and the only remedy at this point is to strip the convicted of their ability to run for future office – a move that would undoubtedly strip millions of voters of their ability to choose a candidate in the next election."[190] Senator Rand Paul (R-KY) tweeted "I object to this unconstitutional sham of an 'impeachment' trial and I will force a vote on whether the Senate can hold a trial of a private citizen."[191] Senator Richard Burr (R-NC) said "A charge like this should go to the Justice Department and be referred for prosecution. Unfortunately, that's not what they're doing," However, Burr ended up voting to convict Trump for the charges on incitement of insurrection.[192]

On January 26, eight senators spoke out against impeachment. Senator James Lankford (R-OK) said "This is not a trial; this is political theater. You cannot remove someone from the office who is already out of office. In this trial, there is no current President, no Chief Justice, and no possibility someone could be removed from office because they are not in any office. In a moment when our nation needs to unite, this trial will only create even deeper divisions."[193] Senator Jim Inhofe (R-OK) tweeted "Given that the penalty for impeachment shall be removed from office, my reading of the Constitution leads me to believe that the Founders did not intend for us to impeach former federal officeholders. I agree with @RandPaul that it's not constitutional to try a former president."[194] Senator John Kennedy (R-LA) said "Today, I voted to affirm that these impeachment proceedings are unconstitutional. Based on the information I have right now, I voted today and will vote again later in the impeachment trial to dismiss the impeachment proceedings against former President Trump."[195] Senator Rand Paul (R-KY) tweeted "This impeachment is nothing more than a partisan exercise designed to further divide the country. Democrats claim to want to unify the country but impeaching a former president, a private citizen, is the antithesis of unity."[196] Senator Richard Shelby (R-AL) told reporters he has "deep reservations whether they should be trying him at all."[197] Senator Roy Blunt (R-MO) tweeted that "I believe the constitutional purpose for presidential impeachment is to remove a president from office, not to punish a person after they have left office."[198] Senator Shelley Moore Capito (R-WV) said "My vote today to dismiss the article of impeachment is based on the fact that impeachment was designed to remove an officeholder from public office. The Constitution does not give Congress the power to impeach a private citizen. This charge is directed at an individual who no longer holds public office. I believe it is time we focus our attention and energies on the numerous challenges our country presently faces. Instead of taking a path of divisiveness, let us heed the call to unity that we have heard spoken so often over the past few weeks."[199] Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC) said "On January 6, I said voting to reject the states' electors was a dangerous precedent we should not set. Likewise, impeaching a former President who is now a private citizen would be equally unwise."[200]

Senators Jim Risch (R-ID) was among a group of Republican senators who have asked Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) how to prevent the Senate from even holding a trial.[201]

Retired Harvard Law School professor Alan Dershowitz, who represented Trump during his first impeachment and had endorsed Biden for president in the 2020 election,[202] opposed another impeachment. He stated that Trump "has not committed a constitutionally impeachable offense" and that he "would be honored to once again defend the Constitution against partisan efforts to weaponize it for political purposes".[203]

George Washington University Law School professor Jonathan Turley wrote an op-ed in The Hill in which he argued that this new impeachment effort would "damage the constitution". While Turley condemns Trump's remarks, he stated that Trump's speech "would be viewed as a protected speech by the Supreme Court". He also noted that Trump "never actually called for violence or riots" and pointed to other remarks made by congressional Democrats last year that similarly encouraged protests that turned violent.[204]

Former National Security Advisor John Bolton called for Trump's resignation;[205] however, he argued against both invocation of the 25th Amendment and impeachment, claiming that it was a "very bad idea", that the 25th Amendment was the "worst drafted" section of the Constitution, and would lead to "two competing presidencies" if invoked and challenged by Trump.[206]

As a counter to the push for impeachment, House Republicans introduced a resolution to censure Trump, sponsored by Brian Fitzpatrick with original cosponsors Tom Reed, Young Kim, John Curtis, Peter Meijer, and Fred Upton; Meijer and Upton announced they would also support impeachment.[207][208][209]

After the attack, Ohio Governor Mike DeWine stated that impeachment was not a wise idea, saying that "if that were to occur more people would be inflamed. There would be less trust in the whole system. We only got two more weeks and the next president will take place at 12 noon on January 20, two weeks to go and that will be it."[210]

On January 12, Trump described the impeachment charge as a "witch hunt" that was "causing tremendous anger" among his supporters.[211]

Public opinion polls

Public opinion polls of impeachment[212]
Pollster Sample size Pop Margin of error Support Oppose Date Citation
YouGov 1,448 RV ±3.3% 50% 42% Jan 6 [213]
Ipsos 500 A ±5.0% 51% 36% Jan 6 [214]
The Hill/HarrisX 964 RV ±3.16% 49% 51% Jan. 6–7 [215]
Axios/Ipsos 536 A ±4.6% 51% 49% Jan. 6–7 [216]
Politico/Morning Consult 1,986 RV ±2.0% 44% 43% Jan. 6–7 [217]
Avalanche Insights 2,009 A 58% 34% Jan 7 [218]
PBS/Marist 875 A ±4.8% 48% 49% Jan 7 [219]
831 RV ±4.9% 49% 48%
HuffPost/YouGov 1,000 RV ±4.1% 47% 41% Jan. 6–8 [220]
Change Research 1,116 LV ±3.4% 51% 47% Jan. 7–8 [221]
ABC/Ipsos 570 A ±4.7% 56% 43% Jan. 8–9 [222]
Quinnipiac University 1,239 RV ±2.8% 52% 45% Jan. 7–10 [223]
Data for Progress 1,129 LV ±2.9% 53% 43% Jan. 9–10 [224]
Vox/Data for Progress 1,233 LV ±2.8% 52% 46% Jan. 8–11 [225]
Navigator Research 1,000 RV 53% 40% Jan. 8–11 [226]
Politico/Morning Consult 1,996 RV ±2.0% 52% 41% Jan. 8–11 [227]

RV = registered voters, LV = likely voters, A = all adults.

See also

Copyright